A Superior Court ruling in November cost a Mississauga condominium corporation more than $50,000, plus its own legal bills, for failing to act reasonably in considering an owner’s renovation requests.

Stephen Moran owns a condominium unit in a 341-unit building on Hillcrest Ave. Its governing declaration says that no owner can make any structural change or alteration to a unit without the prior written consent of the board of directors.

In November, 2021, Moran applied to the board for permission to carry out renovations in the unit. He proposed to install new tiles in the kitchen and washrooms, replace the kitchen counters and cabinets, and supply new bathroom vanities.

The board approved the work only if it started on Dec. 6 and would be completed within four days. The service elevator could only be used twice for a maximum of 20 minutes to bring in and remove materials and equipment.

Moran replied saying the restrictions were unreasonable, that the elevator would be needed for at least three hours to remove the construction debris, and deliveries of supplies could not possibly be scheduled within a 20-minute window.

Moran’s contractors began to work during the scheduled time period, but quickly ran out of time.

on Dec. 22, 2021, Moran retained a lawyer who submitted a proposed construction schedule and two requests for more reasonable access rights. When no response was received for almost three months, Moran began a court application for an order declaring that the condominium was in breach of the Condominium Act, and for an order requiring it to co-operate with him by permitting a reasonable access schedule.

Moran also sought damages as compensation for the losses caused by the condominium.

The building’s property manager never supplied copies of any written rules, policies or procedures that would apply, including anything supporting a 20-minute time limit for the use of the service elevator.

Over the next few months, lawyers for both parties exchanged emails trying, unsuccessfully, to agree on a construction schedule and access to the elevators.

Finally, on Sept. 29, 2022, some 10 months after the original request, the matter came before Justice Marie-Andrée Vermette. Moran’s contractor provided an affidavit stating the work could not possibly be completed within four days. Affidavit evidence submitted on behalf of the board was, in the judge’s words, “replete with hearsay, speculation and general and unsupported statements.”

The judge set out a new construction schedule and ruled that Moran was reasonably entitled to expect that the condominium would consider his renovation requests fairly, take his concerns seriously, and provide timely responses and decisions. The board had done none of this.

Moran’s evidence was that he could not move into the unfinished unit after the sale of his former residence, and suffered damages of almost $36,000 for moving, storage and temporary accommodation.

In November, Justice Vermette ruled that Moran was entitled to an oppression remedy under the Condominium Act, and ordered the board to pay Moran damages of $35,826.93, plus $15,000 in costs.

The outcome of this case serves as a useful lesson for condo boards throughout Ontario.

Bob Aaron is a Toronto real estate lawyer and a contributing columnist for the Star. He can be reached at [email protected] or on Twitter: @bobaaron2


Conversations are opinions of our readers and are subject to the Code of conduct. The Star does not endorse these opinions.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

https://scatterhitam-slot.com powergaming88 powergaming88 powergaming88 powergaming88 powergaming88 powergaming88 powergaming88 powergaming88 slot zeus nolimit city sv388 https://pariamantimur.pariamankota.go.id/assets/ https://sipatudia.bpsdm.sumbarprov.go.id/assets/mahjong/ slot jepang http://simokata.tabanankab.go.id/dist/img/thailand/ scatter hitam slot thailand link slot thailand 777 slot powergaming88 slot luar negeri slot gacor maxwin slot gacor hari ini slot gacor terbaru mahjong ways 2 slot thailand jp slot slot bni slot bri slot bsi slot danamon slot gopay slot server korea slot malaysia slot amerika slot rusia fan tan monopoly live lightning roulette mega ball sweet bonanza candyland mega sic bo mega baccarat andar bahar sbobet88 ktm303 slot dubai slot qris powergaming88 Slot Thailand Slot Zeus Pg Soft Starlight Princess Slot Gacor Maxwin Joker123 Sv388 Slot Thailand Slot Thailand Slot Qris slot thailand joker123 mahjong ways 2 888slot sweet bonanza slot jepang slot thailand slot mahjong ways slot qris slot deposit dana slot dana nolimit city slot thailand sv388 slot888 slot kamboja http://labse.ce.undip.ac.id/sejarah/gacorx/ Slot Thailand Starlight Princess Mahjong Ways 2 Slot Maxwin slot thailand akun pro kamboja slot filipina joker123 slot zeus slot88 slot thailand slot mahjong slot megaways NEW SLOT POLA GACOR Slot Server Luar https://mandiri-gacor.angkolatimur.tapselkab.go.id/ jp slot slot ganas https://cheat-gacor.angkolatimur.tapselkab.go.id/ crazy time live slot qris https://sqris.angkolatimur.tapselkab.go.id/ slot akurat slot bca slot bni qris https://pragmaticplay.dharmasatyasarana.co.id/ https://dana.sidamaju.skom.id/ https://joker123.putramuko.co.id/ https://akun-pro-rusia.mariyadl.sch.id/ slot zeus server thailand server hongkong slot ovo slot gopay slot linkaja joker123 nolimit city sv388 starlight princess mahjong ways pg slot slot zeus sv388 idn slot https://joker123.elearningmansatuokit.sch.id/ slot server thailand slot thailand https://slot-thailand.itr.ac.id/ https://pn-watansoppeng.go.id/media/jui/server-thailand/ https://dinkes.hsu.go.id/wp-content/uploads/server-thailand/ ladangtoto nolimit city koi gate sicbo online roulette online lice casino live22 baccarat online nolimit city slot ovo slot gopay pragmati play starlight princess slot pg soft slot mahjong slot zeus sv388 digmaan slot mania slot zeus slot thailand server thailand ying77 slot thailand judi bola live casino sv388 pg soft slot dana mahjong ways slot mania slot x500 ladangtoto slot server kamboja digmaan digmaan slot88 scv388 sabung ayam online slot live casino sicbo online live casino online slot thailand ladangtoto sv388 ladangtoto powergaming88 66kbet powergaming88 slot thailand ladangtoto slot thailand server thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot gacor ladangtoto2 ying77 bet server thailand slot thailand ying77 slot88 ladangtoto ladangtoto slot maxwin sv388 sv388 slot gacor 66k bet slot dana sabung ayam inline slot mahjong slot toto slot server thailand slot gacor slot server thailand slot gacor slot thailand situs slot wwg slot slot daftar judi slot online indonesia slot gacor slot mawin slot gacor slot thailand slot gacor slot gacor demo slot pragmatic sv388 slot88 pgsoft Daftar Judi Slot Online Indonesia Paling Gacor di Indonesia Daftar Situs Judi Slot Online SLOT88 lucky neko slot gacor slot88 slot kakek slot maxwin slot thailand Slot Mahjong Ways 2 Mudah Jackpot Paus di PG Soft Hari ini 2023 Lucky Neko Situs Slot Gacor Pgsoft Hari Ini SITUS SABUNG AYAM SV388 ONLINE DAFTAR LINK LOGIN APK AGEN SV388